In this comprehensive guide, we rank all 50 state flags, analyze their design quality, symbolism, and history, and determine which flags are true works of vexillology and which ones desperately need a redesign. Whether you’re a flag enthusiast, a design nerd, or just curious about what makes your state’s flag good or terrible, this guide will give you everything you need to join the great American flag debate.
What Makes a Great State Flag? The 5 Basic Principles of Design
Before we dive into ranking individual flags, let’s establish what makes a flag truly great. The North American Vexillological Association (NAVA) has developed five basic principles of good flag design, which have been popularized by educational content creators like CGP Grey. These principles help us evaluate flags objectively rather than relying purely on personal preference.
1. Keep It Simple
A flag should be simple enough that a child can draw it from memory. This doesn’t mean it has to be boring—Colorado’s bold “C” and New Mexico’s Zia sun symbol are both simple yet distinctive. The problem arises when states try to cram complicated state seals with tiny details onto their flags. When a flag is flying 100 feet in the air, those intricate details become invisible blobs.
2. Use Meaningful Symbolism
The best flags tell a story through their symbols. Alaska’s Big Dipper and North Star represent its northern location and the gold rush that shaped its history. Arizona’s copper star honors its mining heritage, while the 13 alternating rays represent both the 13 original colonies and the sun’s rays at sunset. These symbols create an immediate, emotional connection to the state’s identity and heritage.
3. Use 2-3 Basic Colors
Limiting the color palette makes flags more visually striking and easier to manufacture. Texas uses just three colors—red, white, and blue—to create an iconic design. Maryland breaks this rule spectacularly with its four-color heraldic pattern, but it works because the design is bold and deliberate. The problem comes when flags use too many similar shades that blend together from a distance.
4. No Lettering or Seals
This is where many state flags fail catastrophically. Text becomes illegible when the flag is flying or viewed from a distance, and it defeats the entire purpose of having a quick-to-identify symbol. A flag should be recognizable at a glance, not something you need to read like a book. Complex state seals with Latin mottos, dates, and detailed imagery belong on official documents, not flags.
5. Be Distinctive or Be Related
A flag should be unique enough that it’s not confused with others. This is the Achilles’ heel of the “blue bedsheet” flags that dominate the Northeast and Midwest. When Pennsylvania, Virginia, New York, Massachusetts, Maine, and a dozen other states all use the same basic template of a state seal on a blue background, they become interchangeable and forgettable.
The Contenders: Ranking the Best State Flags in America
Now that we’ve established our criteria, let’s look at the state flags that get it right. These flags follow the principles of good design, create strong visual identities, and make their states proud.
Tier 1: The Gold Standard (Iconic Designs)
New Mexico – The undisputed champion of state flag design. New Mexico’s flag features the red Zia sun symbol on a field of gold, representing the Native American Zia Pueblo and the state’s sunshine. It’s instantly recognizable, beautifully simple, and deeply meaningful. The unique color scheme—gold and red instead of the typical red, white, and blue—sets it apart immediately. Design experts and flag enthusiasts consistently rank this as the #1 state flag in America.
Arizona – A close second, Arizona’s flag features 13 alternating red and gold rays emanating from a copper star, representing both the setting sun and the state’s copper mining industry. The bottom half is a solid field of blue representing liberty. It’s bold, colorful, and tells Arizona’s story perfectly. The design is complex enough to be interesting but simple enough to be memorable.
Alaska – Alaska’s flag is a masterpiece of simplicity and symbolism. Eight gold stars form the Big Dipper constellation with the North Star in the upper right corner, all set against a dark blue field. A 13-year-old boy designed this flag in 1927, proving that brilliant design doesn’t require a committee of experts. The stars represent Alaska’s northern location and the hope for its future.
Maryland – The most polarizing entry on this list. Maryland’s flag combines the black and gold Calvert family coat of arms with the red and white Crossland family cross in a bold quartered design. It’s busy, it breaks the color rule, and yet it absolutely works. The “Maryland Brigade” of flag enthusiasts will defend this design to the death, and for good reason—it’s unlike anything else in the United States. You either love it or hate it, but you definitely remember it.
Colorado – Simple, bold, and effective. A stylized “C” wraps around a golden circle on a field of blue and white stripes. The colors represent Colorado’s skies, snow-capped mountains, and red soil, while the gold honors the state’s mining heritage. It’s modern, clean, and instantly recognizable—everything a state flag should be.
Tier 2: Excellent and Distinctive (Strong Contenders)
Texas – The Lone Star State has the lone star flag, and Texans wouldn’t have it any other way. The single white star on blue, with red and white stripes, is simple, meaningful, and iconic. It’s probably the most recognized state flag after California’s bear flag, and it perfectly captures Texas pride and independence.
South Carolina – A white crescent moon and palmetto tree on a deep blue field. The symbols date back to the Revolutionary War, when the palmetto logs of Fort Moultrie absorbed British cannon fire, and the crescent was worn on soldiers’ caps. It’s simple, historical, and elegant.
California – The California Republic flag features a grizzly bear, a red star, and the words “California Republic” on a white field with a red stripe at the bottom. While it technically violates the “no text” rule, the design is so iconic and the text so minimal that it gets a pass. The bear is a powerful symbol of California’s strength and independence.
Tennessee – Three white stars in a blue circle, separated from a red field by a white and blue stripe. The three stars represent Tennessee’s three grand divisions: East, Middle, and West Tennessee. It’s simple, meaningful, and the unique circular element makes it stand out.
Ohio – Ohio’s flag is notable for being the only non-rectangular state flag—it’s a burgee (swallowtail) shape. The red and white stripes represent the original 13 colonies, while the blue triangle with its white stars and red circle represents Ohio’s hills and valleys. The unique shape alone makes it memorable.
The Middle of the Pack: Missed Opportunities and Decent Efforts
Many state flags fall into a gray area—they’re not terrible, but they’re not particularly inspiring either. These flags often have one or two good elements but fail to come together into something truly memorable.
Almost Great But…
Michigan has beautiful imagery including a moose, elk, and an eagle, but it’s all crammed onto a complex state seal that’s impossible to see from a distance. Montana’s flag has striking imagery of mountains, forests, and mining tools, but ruins it by plastering “MONTANA” across the top in large letters. These states had the right idea but couldn’t resist over-complicating things or adding unnecessary text.
Wyoming features a white bison on a blue field with red and white borders—a strong central image that works well. Louisiana uses a pelican feeding its young on a blue field, which is unique but perhaps a bit gruesome when you look closely. These flags are distinctive but lack the visual punch of the top tier.
Distinctive But Dated
Some flags are unique but feel like relics of another era. Oregon is the only state with a different design on each side—the state seal on one side and a beaver on the other. While technically impressive, it’s expensive to produce and the beaver side is rarely seen. Rhode Island’s anchor with the word “HOPE” is simple enough but lacks visual impact. These flags work, but they don’t excel.
The Bottom of the Pack: The Worst State Flags (The “Seal on a Bedsheet” Club)
Now we arrive at the painful part of this ranking: the state flags that violate nearly every principle of good design. These flags are the reason vexillology experts despair and state legislatures occasionally start redesign movements.
The Classic Failure: Blue Banners with State Seals
The most common design failure among American state flags is what’s derisively called the “seal on a bedsheet” or “SOB” flag. These flags follow an identical template: take your state seal (a complex circular design with tiny text, dates, Latin mottos, and intricate imagery) and slap it in the center of a blue rectangle. From a distance, these flags are completely indistinguishable from one another.
The worst offenders include:
Pennsylvania – A blue field with the state coat of arms. Generic and forgettable.
Nebraska – Another blue seal flag with an additional banner reading “March 1, 1867.” The date makes it even worse.
Kansas – Blue background, state seal, “KANSAS” written on top. Triple violation of good design principles.
Maine – Blue field, state seal with a moose and pine tree that you can’t see unless you’re standing right next to it.
New York, Illinois, Wisconsin, Idaho, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota (old flag), Nevada, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Oregon (reverse side), and Vermont – All variations on the same disappointing theme. Some have slightly different shades of blue, some have the state name plastered on them, but they’re all fundamentally the same boring design.
Special Cases of Awfulness
Virginia – Virginia’s flag technically falls into the seal-on-blue category, but it deserves special mention because its seal depicts Virtus (virtue) stepping on the chest of Tyranny—making it the only state flag featuring a “bared titty,” as one Reddit user colorfully noted. It’s memorable for the wrong reasons, but the underlying design is still just another forgettable blue banner.
Washington – At least Washington tried to be different by using a green background instead of blue. However, it’s still just a state seal in the center, and the seal features a portrait of George Washington—making it the only state flag with a realistic human face on it, which is just odd.
Alabama and Florida – Both feature a simple red X (or cross) on a white background. While this is certainly simple, critics argue that a red X looks more like a “Do Not Enter” sign or a mark for rejection than a symbol of state pride. They lack the meaningful symbolism that makes a flag truly great.
A New Wave: Recent State Flag Redesigns (Mississippi, Utah, Minnesota)
The good news is that some states are waking up to the fact that their flags need improvement. Recent years have seen several successful redesigns that prove it’s possible to create modern, meaningful state flags that residents can be proud of.
Mississippi’s Magnolia Flag (2020)
In 2020, Mississippi made history by retiring the last state flag to incorporate Confederate battle flag imagery and adopting a beautiful new design. The new flag features a white magnolia blossom (the state flower) on a blue field, with red and gold stripes and the phrase “In God We Trust.” While it does include text, the flag is a massive improvement over its predecessor and represents a fresh start for the state. The magnolia is large enough to be visible from a distance, and the overall design is clean and modern.
Utah’s New Beehive Flag (2024)
Utah replaced its seal-on-blue flag with a striking modern design featuring a prominent beehive (representing industry and unity) on a dark blue field with a white mountain peak and red rock formation. The design is bold, simple, and instantly recognizable—everything the old flag wasn’t. The new flag honors Utah’s heritage while creating a contemporary symbol that Utahns can rally behind.
Minnesota’s New Flag (2024)
Minnesota said goodbye to yet another seal-on-blue flag and adopted a modern design featuring a white eight-pointed star (the North Star) on a dark blue field with a light blue shape representing the state’s waters. The design is abstract yet meaningful, simple yet distinctive. It represents a bold departure from tradition and shows what’s possible when states embrace modern design principles.
Frequently Asked Questions About State Flags
What is universally considered the best US state flag?
New Mexico is frequently ranked #1 by the North American Vexillological Association (NAVA), design experts, and flag enthusiasts. Its simple Zia sun symbol on a gold field is the gold standard of state flag design.
What is the worst state flag in America?
There’s no single “worst,” but the “seal on a bedsheet” flags are universally criticized. Pennsylvania, Nebraska, Kansas, and Maine are often cited as the least effective designs because they’re generic, cluttered, and impossible to distinguish from a distance.
Why are so many state flags blue?
The prevalence of blue flags likely stems from two sources: the influence of the American flag’s blue canton, and a 19th-century trend of using military-style regimental colors. Many state flags were adopted during or after the Civil War when military traditions heavily influenced state symbolism.
Which state flag has a different shape?
Ohio’s flag is the only non-rectangular state flag. It’s a swallowtail burgee—a pennant shape with a triangular notch cut from the fly edge. This unique shape makes Ohio’s flag instantly recognizable.
Why did Mississippi change its flag?
In 2020, Mississippi retired its flag because it incorporated the Confederate battle flag in its design. This made Mississippi the last state to remove Confederate imagery from its flag. The new Magnolia flag was adopted through a public vote and represents the state’s commitment to unity and progress.
Which state flag has a bear on it?
California’s state flag features the California grizzly bear, along with a red star and the words “California Republic.” The flag dates back to the short-lived California Republic of 1846 and has become one of the most iconic and recognizable state flags in America.
What are the rules for good flag design?
The five basic principles established by NAVA are: (1) Keep it simple—a child should be able to draw it from memory, (2) Use meaningful symbolism, (3) Use 2-3 basic colors, (4) No lettering or seals, and (5) Be distinctive or be related. Following these principles leads to flags that are memorable, meaningful, and effective.
Does Texas have the best flag?
Texas’s flag is definitely one of the most recognizable and popular among residents, and it ranks highly for its simplicity and symbolism. However, design experts often prefer New Mexico or Arizona for their unique color schemes and even simpler designs. That said, Texas’s flag perfectly captures the state’s independent spirit and pride.
Conclusion: What’s Your Favorite State Flag?
The debate over America’s best and worst state flags reveals something deeper than just design preferences—it’s about identity, pride, and how we represent ourselves. The best flags, like New Mexico’s Zia sun and Arizona’s copper star rays, prove that simplicity and symbolism can create powerful, lasting symbols that residents embrace. The worst flags, drowning in illegible seals and forgettable blue backgrounds, serve as cautionary tales of what happens when committees prioritize officiousness over design.
Recent redesigns in Mississippi, Utah, and Minnesota offer hope that change is possible. When states commit to modern design principles and meaningful symbolism, they can create flags that unite residents and inspire pride. The seal-on-blue flags that dominate so many state capitols don’t have to be permanent fixtures.
Whether you’re a card-carrying member of the Maryland Brigade defending your state’s polarizing heraldic masterpiece, a Texan who believes the Lone Star is perfection, or a New Mexican who knows you’ve already won the flag competition, the debate itself is part of what makes state flags fascinating. These symbols represent our collective identity, our history, and our values—and they’re worth getting passionate about.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE BLOG POSTS
“In a world of instant takes and AI-generated noise, John Authers writes like a human. His words carry weight—not just from knowledge, but from care. Readers don’t come to him for headlines; they come for meaning. He doesn’t just explain what happened—he helps you understand why it matters. That’s what sets him apart.”